Nile| Egypt says: Ethiopia's dam will wait for the Experts' Panel

(Daniel Berhane)

Egyptian Minister claims he can not say for sure that the Renaissance dam project has negative effects “on Egypt’s share of the Nile water”.

Minister Irrigation and Water Resources, Dr. Mohamed Bahaa El-Din, made the remark to Egyptian reporters during his visit to a water project on Sunday.

Dr. El-Din said that he awaits for the findings of the International Panel of Experts submits its report next month, noting that the Panel includes international experts and will decide the potential pros and cons expected of the construction of the dam.

The minister added that based on the Panel’s report Egypt and Sudan will start negotiations with Ethiopia.

The negotiations would be to minimize the negative impacts, if any, and to optimize of the potential positive impacts, which were mentioned by the former Ethiopian Prime Minister, as well as to work another parallel project to avoid negative impacts of the Renaissance dam.

In a separate remark to an Egyptian paper published on Sunday, Dr. El-Din claimed that Ethiopia will not build the dam until the the Panel completes its work.

He said that what is being reported about the Renaissance dam construction is “just digging the foundations and related works”.

The irrigation minister also claimed that the Panel will complete its work at the end of May next year.

Egypt and Sudan are working in coordination to discuss with Ethiopian officials for clarifications of the negative impacts of the dam, thus to avoid them.

It is to be recalled that, Ethiopian Foreign Minister, Tedros Adhanom (Ph.D.), said on February 27 that the construction will not be put on hold no matter what, even though the government is ready to make some adjustments, if found necessary depending on the findings of the report.

Ethiopian officials recently reported that the project is 19.6% complete and works are underway to divert the water from the natural course before the rain season starts. The

The diversion works are said to include “a 120 m wide, 1,100 m long diversion channel excavated on the right bank of the river, discharging wet season flows (14, 700 m3/s) and 4 box culverts located at the dam foundation level on the left bank of the river, capable to discharging the dry season flows (2,700 m3/s).”

The water diversion work will be followed by “the construction of the the concrete gravity dam, a gated spillway and rock-hill Saddle Dam with an emergency spillway in correspondence of its right abutment”.

Last week, China Electric Power Equipment and Technology Co.Itd. signed an agreement for the construction of the power transmissions of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam. Chinese loan will cover 85% of the $1.2 bln USD cost of the work, which is to scheduled to be completed in two years.
*************

(Compiled from various Arabic sites of Egypt, with the help of Google translation service)

9.14540.489673

View Comments (8)

  • Dear all peace loving Egyptians,
    The Ethiopian government and people UNDERSTAND your genuine concerns. TRUST US.. We have neither an intention nor an agenda that puts your life in danger. We are not constructing a dam whose objective decreases the natural amount of water flow of the Nile. You don't have to be a scientist to understand this fact- check the simple logic and technique behind Hydro-Electric Power (HEP) generation. We ONLY NEED THE WATER'S KINETIC ENERGY TO ROTATE THE TURBINES to produce mechanical energy which afterwards will be converted into electric power that eventually produces HEP. The diverted water afterwards joins the normal course of the river and continues its flow. It's not like we're gonna use the water as a fuel to produce energy.

    Therefore, there is no need to panic... we've already been caring for the great Egyptian people for thousands of years. There's no single reason why we should irresponsibly construct a dam now that puts Egyptian (and Sudanese) lives at risk when we can actually do it without causing any trouble to millions of livelihoods of the same.

    May God bless both Egyptians and Ethiopians... people of great civilization !

  • Dear Ethiopians
    You have full right to get benefit from your resources.We in Egypt ,we don’t like the idea of war with ethiopia
    You want the dam for elecricity ,to get rid of poverty.these are noble causes.But the dam has a real dangers on us.
    for example
    we in egypt:-
    1-in Egypt our population is 84,314,326 people according to wiki
    and our water consumption is 64 billion cubic meter whit 55 billion from Nile….that means average per capita water use in Egypt is 700 cubic meters [per year]
    while below 1000 cubic meters means water poverty

    2-in Ethiopia population is 91,195,675
    and your average per capita water use is 1,355 cubic meter and most of it not from the river

    97.5% of Egypt is desert …nothing more
    every shortage of 4 billion of cubic meter of water consumption means ….loss of 70 million m of agricultural lands…..2 million families in streets…loss of food production by 5 billion dollar

    if you started to fill the dam which its capacity is 63,000,000,000 m3 in 6 years as your government said
    we will loss 19 billion cubic meter of Nile water

    and this means DISASTER .this means KILLING innocent people for electricity
    which only the foreign companies & bankers that will profit from it by dept that they paid for your governement and us Ethiopians & Egyptians would benefit nothing….

    I am sure if your government were honest with you dear Good Ethiopian people ,you wouldn’t approve that

    war would solve nothing and also disrespect to others life

    i have a dream that both nations become good friends and allies against poverty and corruption
    and this can become true by good listenning to each other

    sorry for my bad english
    P.S. these numbers are real ….if you don’t believe it .try to search it

    • sir so far we r poor we cannot feed ourselves because of ur country's historic enemity on us for over 1500year's by distablizing us, yes we tried to leave nile for u and focus on others but ur leaders were cruel and mocking on us by influencing any development projects in our country. Now onwards z red line was crossed already, we will build our resources otherwise we will confront whatever comes, If ur country try to attack our dam we will attack z aswan or we just pour out z nuclear slugs or z expired pesticides in our stocks to z nile, we don't have any choice. then u will buy bottled waters from elsewhere or desalinize z redsea.

      • I always read your ministers and intellectuals comments and views about “Egypt’s share of water” and “Historical right” and I wonder who gave you this share of water and historical right which we Ethiopians didn’t know?
        Do you have any evidence and concrete justification for this? No one afraid to go to war with you even if this is not our choice.
        This is 21st century and you better think accordingly.
        If we can’t use our resource you can’t use it too.
        Please come to your mind and think twice. Don’t be greedy we can share the resource not by force but by negotiation. Tell the truth to your people and politicians .the resource is on our hand and we will never ask for permission to use our resource. If we work for the benefit of all riparian countries we all will benefit .
        I personally do not want Egypt to get starved because of shortage of water but this cannot happen by threatening us or by any force but by peace and mutual trust.
        I will advice you open your eyes and see mutual benefits for both people other than being greedy in thoughts and action.
        Please please don't tell us to stop building our dam because we will never and ever stop it.

Leave a Comment

This website uses cookies.