Ethiopia Rejects Recycled Human Right Watch Report

Ethiopian government ‘categorically rejected’ the allegations on the recent report of the Human Rights Watch, titled ‘Development without Freedom: How aid underwrites suppression in Ethiopia’.[Read Here]

In its press statement, issued by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Wednesday, the government recalled the investigation conducted by the Development Assistance Group(DAG), a 26 aid agencies consortium. The aid consortium vindicated the government from allegations of politicizing aid in its investigation on January 2010.

It should be noted that the report released by the Human Rights Watch on Tuesday is based on a research allegedly conducted from June-Dec.2009. In fact, as any reader can observe, the report is simply a rewriting of its March 2010 Report, titled ‘One Hundred Ways of Putting Pressure’. [Please compare the Methodology section of the the two reports.] Unable to achieve its objective of pressurizing the Ethiopian government, Human Right Watch chose to recycle its previous report and publish it with a new title and a few new inputs. I will post a thorough analysis of the recent report as soon as possible. [Related:Media Darling: HRW’s 10 flagrant blunders]

Here is the press statement issued by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Wednesday.

****************

Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia
Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Press Statement
The Government of Ethiopia refutes claims of politicized aid.

The Government of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia has noted with dismay the extraordinary attack launched against it by Human Rights Watch. It categorically rejects the accusation that it politicizes the use of development aid in any shape or form or that it has misused any of the development aid so generously provided by the international community.

The allegations made by Human Rights Watch simply do not reflect reality. In January this year, the Development Assistance Group, a 26 aid agency consortium in Ethiopia, investigated similar allegations. Its report found that safeguards for donor programs were largely working well, that the programs were achieving results and the monitoring mechanisms were sufficient.

Ethiopia is currently achieving considerable success in development. It has reached four of the Millennium Development Goals and is on track for two more. The government has been and remains entirely committed to transparency in its dealings with the international community and with aid donors on the basis of mutual trust and responsibility, and of accountability and transparency.

It is impossible to believe from its latest report that these are principles to which Human Rights Watch is prepared to adhere to in any genuine manner. It is, therefore, hardly surprising that Human Rights Watch should try to threaten the provision of development aid to Ethiopia. Indeed, this would appear to be an attempt by Human Rights Watch gratuitously to blackmail the international community as part of its ongoing vendetta against the government of Ethiopia.

[Seal of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs]


more recommended stories